10) The Comics Are Perfect, Why Change It?
There’s an argument to be made that a TV show that differentiates from the comic is a good thing because of the reasons Kirkman has voiced before. It could be a totally different creative rehash of past events that keep comic fans guessing while reeling in new fans that may pick up the comics for a completely different experience. I don’t argue that – hell, I think it’s a novel idea. So what’s my problem? AMC’s The Walking Dead has been trying this for three seasons now, and has failed mightily in this respect.
Any way you look at it, Kirkman’s comic exists in a league of its own compared to the show. It’s the minors versus the majors. Rookies versus the Veterans. Pros Versus Joes.
But it’s not just here and there – it’s every aspect. Story, horror, gore, character depth, tension, action, entertainment, replay value, excitement, insanity, creativity, boundary ignorance, morality questioning, mental stimulation – the television show is nothing but a hollow shell of a larger, better, faster, stronger version of The Walking Dead. I know some people aren’t into reading and don’t want to suffer the stigma of owning a comic, but I can’t stress enough how hooked I was after only reading Volume 1 of The Walking Dead. Since then, I’ve never finished a volume in less than one consecutive reading, being entirely too gripping to peel myself away from.
If you’re struggling with the TV show, there’s no doubt you’ll appreciate the comic – it’s hardcore horror with an amazing take on a post-apocalyptic zombie world. If you love the TV show and think it’s intense, the comic will blow you away, but if the show is already too much to handle, then approach the comics with caution – but still try it.
I think I’ve said enough on the topic, but I want to hear what you think. Comic fans, do you agree with me? Television fans, am I being too harsh? Sound off in the comments!